Articles

The Silent Struggle: Motherhood’s Disappearing Act

by Jaime Fryburg, Psy.D.
May 14, 2025

The moment a baby arrives, an extraordinary vanishing trick occurs. The woman who brought that baby into the world suddenly becomes invisible—except as a vessel for everyone else’s needs and expectations. She has become “mom.” While visitors flock to see the baby, few truly see the person who just endured a seismic physical and psychological transformation. This isn’t just metaphorical; it’s literally written in her cells.

The Body Snatcher Phenomenon

Even before a baby has made its first appearance on Earth, a woman changes and adapts her body to keep that baby safe- eating, drinking, and moving her body differently. But lifestyle changes are only what’s happening on the surface. Let’s talk microchimerism—the startling biological reality where fetal cells migrate into the mother’s body and take up permanent residence. These aren’t just temporary squatters; they’re setting up shop in her brain, heart, lungs, and skin for decades. Motherhood isn’t just a role—it’s a cellular colonization that rewires a woman’s physical existence.

Meanwhile, society hands new mothers an impossible script: Heal from what amounts to major physical trauma while functioning on catastrophic sleep deprivation. Look presentable. Feel blessed. And please, do it quickly and quietly so everyone can stop feeling uncomfortable about your messy reality.

The Identity Earthquake

Motherhood isn’t just a new chapter—it’s a different book entirely. The neurological rewiring alone is staggering; a mother’s brain physically changes during pregnancy and postpartum, optimizing for different priorities and responses.

Yet once the baby arrives, the woman she was often disappears into her role. Society praises and judges the “mom” in equal measure, but forgets the person grappling with a profound identity shift. We ask about the baby’s sleep schedule but rarely inquire about the complex emotional terrain a new mother is navigating.

The contradictory pressures mount quickly: Breastfeed, but not where anyone might see. Use formula, but prepare for judgment. Return to work, but don’t appear too eager. Stay home, but maintain your professional edge. And through it all, maintain a household, nurture a relationship, and maybe even attempt a shower every few days.

The Self-Care Myth

“Take time for yourself!” they chirp, as if suggesting a spa day to someone who can barely find time to brush their teeth. What these well-meaning people fail to understand is that “taking time” isn’t just about physical availability—it’s about mental bandwidth.

The truth? When you’re leaking from multiple orifices and haven’t slept more than two consecutive hours in weeks, “me time” isn’t exactly rejuvenating. It’s often just another exhausting performance of normalcy that leaves you counting the minutes until you can return to your sweatpants. In fact, many new moms might even stare blankly, unsure of what taking time for yourself even means these days. The very suggestion that a 30-minute coffee break will somehow reset your depleted nervous system is almost comically disconnected from reality. 

America’s Postpartum Desert

The statistics paint a grim picture: 23% of employed American women return to work within 10 days of giving birth. Let that sink in. Ten. Days.

That’s barely enough time for the initial bleeding to slow down, let alone for hormones to stabilize or sleep patterns to establish. The physical healing alone takes weeks, yet nearly half of all working mothers in America are back at work before six weeks postpartum—often sitting uncomfortably on donut pillows during meetings while trying not to visibly leak breast milk through their carefully selected “professional” attire.

Even more alarming is the mental health crisis hiding in plain sight. With fewer than 20% of mothers screened for postpartum mental health disorders and suicide ranking among the leading causes of death for new mothers, we’re failing women at a systemic level.

Beyond Mother’s Day Platitudes

What new mothers need isn’t another scented candle or flowery card one day a year. They need recognition of the massive transformation they’re undergoing—physically, mentally, emotionally—and practical support that matches the scale of this life change.

They need partners who step up without being asked, friends who drop off meals without expecting to hold the baby or stay to hang out, and workplaces that understand recovery from childbirth takes months, not days. They need healthcare providers who check on their mental health as diligently as they track the baby’s weight gain. They need tangible macro-level social supports that provide what they need to get through this monumental life experience in one piece. 

Most importantly, they need space to be honest about the complex reality of motherhood—that it can simultaneously be the most profound love they’ve ever experienced and the most depleting role they’ve ever assumed.

The path forward isn’t about “bouncing back” to who they were before. It’s about society making room for who they’re becoming—recognizing that on the other side of this metamorphosis is not just a mother, but a transformed woman who deserves to be seen in her complete, complex humanity.

If you know a new mother, ask her—really ask her—how she’s doing. Then listen without rushing to solutions or platitudes. Bear witness to her transformation. And remember: behind every “mom” is a woman finding her way back to a new version of herself, piece by piece, in a journey that deserves our deepest respect and most thoughtful support.